Updated October 17, 2026 · SumCue Editorial Team
Top car insurance compared in the United States
49 providers available in the United States, ranked for the United States.
We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings. Partners with a live offer in your country come first, then every other brand by score. How we rank
| Order | Provider | Score | Key facts | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  LemonadeTop pickPartner Rover gift card for new Lemonade Pet policyholders | 9.1/10 |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 2 | NationwidePartner | 9.1/10 |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 3 |  AllstatePartner | 9.5/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
| 4 |  American ModernPartner | 9.5/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
| 5 | TravelersPartner | 9.5/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
| 6 |  AmicaPartner | 9.4/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
| 7 |  Good Sam Insurance AgencyPartner Up To 50% off Roadside Assistance Plans | 9.4/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
| 8 |  State FarmPartner Bundle auto and renters insurance: up to $900 average annual household savings | 9.4/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
| 9 |  Zurich Kotak General InsurancePartner Zurich Kotak General Insurance offers car, bike, travel and health insurance plans in India. | 9.4/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
| 10 |  American FamilyPartner | 9.3/10 |
| ReviewCompareSee alternatives |
Licensed in the United States
- American Modern
- California Department of Insurance
- Travelers
- State of Connecticut
- Amica
- NAIC (state of domicile Rhode Island)
- Liberty Mutual
- NAIC
- Liberty Mutual
- Iowa (state insurance licence)
- Liberty Mutual
- California (state insurance licence)
- Progressive
- California Department of Insurance (Progressive Advantage Agency, Inc.)
- Progressive
- Texas Department of Insurance (Progressive Advantage Agency, Inc.)
- Progressive
- California Department of Insurance (CP Pet Insurance Services, LLC)
- Progressive
- Iowa Insurance Division (Companion Protect Agency, LLC)
- Progressive
- Florida Department of Financial Services (Companion Protect Agency, LLC)
- USAA
- FDIC
- Europ Assistance
- NAIC
- The Hartford
- NAIC
- Acceptance Insurance
- Tennessee Department of Insurance
- Acceptance Insurance
- Alabama Department of Insurance
- Acceptance Insurance
- Arizona Department of Insurance
- Acceptance Insurance
- Arkansas Insurance Department
- Acceptance Insurance
- California Department of Insurance
- Acceptance Insurance
- Colorado Division of Insurance
Other rankings
Browse by category
- Savings in the United States
- Savings accounts in the United States
- Fixed-rate bonds and term deposits in the United States
- Cash management accounts in the United States
- Loans in the United States
- Personal loans in the United States
- Payday and short-term loans in the United States
- Mortgages in the United States
- Credit and debit cards in the United States
- Credit cards in the United States
- Debit cards in the United States
- Prepaid cards in the United States
- Investing in the United States
- Stock and ETF brokers in the United States
- Trading platforms in the United States
- Forex brokers in the United States
- Robo-advisors in the United States
- Gold and precious metals dealers in the United States
- Insurance in the United States
- Life insurance in the United States
- Health insurance in the United States
- Home insurance in the United States
- Travel insurance in the United States
- Crypto in the United States
- Crypto exchanges in the United States
- Crypto wallets in the United States
- Stocks and shares ISAs in the United States
- Pensions and SIPPs in the United States
- Pet insurance in the United States
- Balance transfer cards in the United States
- Budgeting apps in the United States
- Tax software in the United States
- Credit monitoring in the United States
- Credit repair in the United States
- Debt relief in the United States
- Wills and trusts in the United States
- Cashback and coupon apps in the United States
- Paid survey and reward apps in the United States